| CASE STUDY >
The nuts and bolts of business
Written by: René Jakl
Photo by: René Jakl
Just like buying rolls from a local
bakery or from the Odkolek franchise, in recent years people
have gotten used to buying screws, hammers, saws, and drills
at either a hardware store or at Bøenda.
THE GOLDEN AGE of the mid-90s, when 40 hardware stores throughout
the Czech Republic carried the Bøenda sign, may be a thing of the
past, but in the tools and fasteners segment, the Bøenda firm continues
to lead.
Buy a hardware
store for KCS 50,000
In the revolutionary year of 1990, Václav Bøenda (30 at the time)
was the manager of the Household Goods store on Jeèná street in
Prague. "The shelves were left from the days of the Austro-Hungarian
empire, maintenance had been neglected, and no one was willing
to make any repairs," Bøenda says. But he adds that the shop
had a good reputation, something that is especially appreciated
at hardware stores. Prague residents and people from the country
alike shopped there. "Furthermore, it was possible to park
in front of the shop at that time, which is no longer the case," Bøenda
says, recalling an advantage that the newly built DIY stores in
the city outskirts usurped a few years later.
| |
Benchmark
- extensive product assortment, including specialized
items
- high quality and large number of expert employees
- long-term knowledge of the market
- well-established brand |
In the shop, no one was interested in management of the household
goods section, so Bøenda acquired it under a lease. Because there
were long lines of people waiting to get into the shop and business
was good, Bøenda decided to build a retail outlet network. Within
the framework of the so-called small privatization, he started buying
up more hardware stores, generally for starting prices of about KCS
50,000. While this sum didn't include the value of inventories worth
millions of crowns, for which Bøenda had to take out bank loans, or
the real estate on which he had to pay rent, he thinks the price was
cheap, even at the time. "No one was interested in hardware stores,
and the 50,000 crowns could be recouped in one shop within a month
without any problem," Bøenda says.
In 1991 shops were added in Podolí, Bøevnov, on Dlouhá street, on
Kubánské square, and in Michle, as well as two outlets outside of
Prague - in Odolená Voda and Nymburk. In November of the same year,
Bøenda opened a wholesale warehouse in an industrial complex above
the Libeò train station that a Japanese investor had just bought in
auction. He also needed to get rid of excess hardware inventory worth
CZK 50 million, and Bøenda bought it from him gradually. At the end
of 1991 eight retail shops and one wholesale store bore the Bøenda
name, and they employed about 70 people. "I'm a scatterbrain," says
Bøenda, sitting behind a huge pile of paperwork in his office. "Over
the years I've learned that one who insists on order and dwells on
details generally doesn't do very well in business," he says
with a smile.
In the years to come, Bøenda expanded more slowly. He discovered that
the time for consolidation came after the rapid growth. "I had
to create a wage system, so that people wouldn't leave when salaries
rose in other places, to make accounting between the stores more transparent,
and to unify warehouse records," Bøenda says. Individual shops
had their peak sales in 1991 and 1992. "Our largest total monthly
sales reached 47 million crowns, and the extraordinary record for
an individual store, 10 million crowns in one month, is held by our
former Kubánské square outlet," he adds, describing the salad
days.
The firm focused exclusively on carrying hardware, canceling kitchen
equipment and electrical appliance sales. The next step was to gradually
limit wholesale operations, for which Bøenda had several reasons:
wholesale customers were often late in paying, or they didn't pay
at all, independent hardware stores didn't want to support their largest
competitor's wholesaler through their purchases, and the pricing policies
of Czech manufacturers didn't benefit the wholesaler, either. Some
manufacturers gave merchants commissions of 5% or even less, mainly
in order to keep the end price down. Many of them paid dearly for
this, even though they offered high quality products. "When the
American company Stanley acquired TONA Peèky, a Czech key maker, they
immediately gave me a 47% commission, 30% for retail sales and 17%
for wholesale. Unlike the others, they are still on the market," Bøenda
notes.
DIY
stores - heavyweight competitors
In the mid-90s Bøenda's chain of hardware stores reached its greatest
size. At one time there were 31, and the total gradually reached
40. But in 1996 and 1997 the favorable leases expired for many
Bøenda stores, and the new real estate owners raised the rents
markedly. Also, the well established hardware stores came up against
competition - specialized DIY stores like OBI, Hornbach, and Bauhaus.
In addition, new hypermarkets like Tesco and Carrefour featured
tool departments. Despite all of the shortcomings of the giant
stores, starting with insufficient numbers of employees, general
inaccessibility for customers without cars, and the need to make
purchases in large quantities, Czech customers came to like them.
Large parking lots, advertising, and sales did their job.
Bøenda responded by placing greater emphasis on specialized items
(see sidebar, p. 32) and by cutting back on the number of stores. "I
sold some of them, and in other places I terminated the leases,
transferring the inventories, along with my best employees, to
other outlets," recalls the ambitious entrpreneur. He currently
owns two stores in Prague and four outside the city, with sales
of about CZK 10 million a month. The situation has been stabilized
for several years, and his firm is still considered the leader
in retail sales of hardware goods. At his main wholesale outlet
in Prague 3, he organizes presentations, and in the future he plans
to open a tool rental shop. "The most expensive items are
goods we don't have, and this is costing us customers," says
Bøenda, summing up the firm's strategy.
| Goods
from A to Z
The list of more than 16,000 items at Bøenda hardware stores
reads like a primer for the household handyman. It includes
cordless drills, adapters, shower fixtures, angular grinders,
tinwork tools, and 150 W bulbs, and rope ladders. Legendary
Czech handymen are not the main shoppers according to Václav
Bøenda, instead they are professionals. "Builders, craftspeople,
and buyers from factories and various firms buy from us," Bøenda
says, describing his current customers. This was one of the
reasons he decided to locate his wholesale outlet behind
the rail freight terminal Praha-ikov, in the area of today's
construction boom.
"
DIY shops offer only a single type of grinding disk, while
we carry ten different abrasion degrees, with holes for suction
removal or without. A customer needs only to tell us the
type of grinder he has, and we sell him the appropriate disk," says
Bøenda. For example, an entire sales section is dedicated
to a wide variety of screwdrivers. Customers can buy the
precise number of screws or nuts that they want, not a full
package as is the case at other stores.
|
| Other "Bøendas"
In the '90s the hardware market lacked any important chains,
but some independent shops managed to prosper. These include
the popular hardware store V. J. Rousek in Nusle and Truhláø & Co.
in Smíchov (and later in Kobylisy). Bøenda's old store on
Moskevská street is called Jirásko, claiming to have been
founded in 1896. Another large hardware store in Michle,
which was among the first Bøenda bought, is now called Kostka.
People with good memories certainly remember the traditional
U Rotta hardware store on Malé námìstí, which was replaced
by a delicatessen and wine shop.
In the beginning of the '90s Unimarket constituted the only
large competing chain, but hardware was only marginal to
its business. According to Bøenda, Unimarket was built by
the former heads of household goods out of the most lucrative
and largest stores outside of the downtown district. "Of
course they had information as to which shops were making
money, but they were only interested in sales of, say, four
million a month," Bøenda says. Paradoxically, Unimarket
paid dearly for the aggressive arrival of the DIY shops,
which were close to the Unimarket stores in both location
and product assortment. |
|